Summary
Summary
"Stunningly crafted and constantly surprising . . . An utterly convincing love story about two people destined to be together somehow, no matter what."-- The Times
A dazzling novel about the ways the smallest decisions give shape to our lives, The Versions of Us charts a relationship through three possible futures. Cambridge, 1958. Late for class, Eva Edelstein swerves to miss a dog and crashes her bike. Jim Taylor hurries to help her. In that brief moment, three outcomes are born for Eva and Jim. As the strands of their lives weave together and apart across the decades from college through wildly different successes and disappointments, seductions and betrayals, births and funerals, joys and sorrows, the only constant is the power of their connection. A #1 UK bestseller, The Versions of Us is a tour de force of storytelling.
"One Day meets Sliding Doors."-- Elle
"I simply adored this wonderful novel."--Jessie Burton, New York Times bestselling author of The Miniaturist
"A joy."-- The Guardian
"Enchanting."-- People
"Imagines the delicious prospect of romantic do-overs, cleverly negotiating the tricky and often dizzying terrain of three versions of first love . . . A masterly romantic study of love's choices and consequences."-- Publishers Weekly (starred review)
"Triumphant."-- The Sunday Telegraph
"Barnett renders an irresistible concept in sweet, cool prose--a bit like a choose-your-own-adventure book in which you don't have to choose."--Observer
"Reading this ambitious first novel is like putting together the pieces of a complex puzzle. The challenge pays off--only when the puzzle is complete can readers see the whole panoramic picture."-- Library Journal
Reviews (5)
Publisher's Weekly Review
British journalist Barnett's debut novel imagines the delicious prospect of romantic do-overs, cleverly negotiating the tricky and often dizzying terrain of three versions of first love. Eva and Jim first cross paths in 1958, and in "Version One," aspiring writer Eva's bike runs over a nail and law student Jim fixes it, with the pair falling instantly in love and marrying. In "Version Two," Eva's bike misses the nail, and she marries her actor boyfriend, David. "Version Three" starts similarly to the first version, but this time, Eva leaves Jim when she discovers she's pregnant with David's child. The stories and careers variously unfold across 50 years-the "Version Two" Eva and Jim finally meet in 1963 in New York-with parents aging, children growing up and moving on, spouses moving in and out, with Eva's writing and Jim's painting flourishing or withering depending on the version. The constants are love and death-and the portraits of Eva that Jim has drawn. In the first version, Eva views the one portrait as a "version of her. His version, or the version she once offered him." In the second version, a 1977 triptych depicts "three couples. Three lives. Three possible versions," a reminder of Jim's declaration that "you were there with me all along." In the third version, the painting feels like something Jim had long ago forgotten. Barnett's evocative presentation is a masterly romantic study of love's choices and consequences, leaving wide open just what constitutes a perfect ending. Agent: Sally Wofford-Girand, Union Literary. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Booklist Review
In her first novel, Barnett speculates about the effect choice and chance have on fate by imagining three distinct lives for Eva Edelstein and Jim Taylor. All three versions of their story begin in 1958, when Eva, who wants to be a writer, and Jim, who dreams of being an artist, are students at Cambridge. In Version One, Jim stops to offer assistance when Eva's bicycle tire goes flat, and a few years later, they marry. In Version Two, their Cambridge meeting never takes place, and except for a few chance encounters, their tracks don't converge until late in life. In Version Three, Eva is already pregnant when Jim helps her with her tire, and though they fall in love, she leaves him to marry the father of her child. The narrative shuffles through shifting relationships, different sets of children, different degrees of professional success, different joys and disappointments. An intriguing exploration of the many roads not taken, though readers may feel they need a spreadsheet to keep track of who, what, where, and why in each version.--Quinn, Mary Ellen Copyright 2016 Booklist
Guardian Review
This Sliding Doors-style romantic drama riffs on the chance encounters that can define a life Every couple has their "what might have been". As a child I can still remember the dramatic thrill of my own potential nonexistence -- my parents broke up as teenagers then ran into each other on the street years later. I met my husband on a holiday outing following a chance encounter on a Miami beach. Every one of us has many, many roads not taken. And we know deep down how many unions are formed by good timing and suitability rather than random lightning bolts -- otherwise, it would be statistically astonishing just how many people fall in love at the age of 28, at the same time as all their friends. Meanwhile, the appeal of wondering how life might have turned out had you stuck with somebody else can be seen in the astonishing numbers of Facebook citations in divorce petitions. All of the above goes towards making this novel so much fun. The Versions of Us could be described as Sliding Doors, except with three stories instead of two; Life After Life, without all the messy deaths; or The Warlock of Firetop Mountain, without (slightly disappointingly) a big fire-breathing dragon. In version one, Eva and Jim meet and fall in love at university in the 1950s; in version two, they just miss one another; and in version three, it all goes horribly wrong. It is an alternate universe romance: a book of missed chances, as the characters wind in and out of each other's lives in a variety of ways. It is indisputably a novel that demands to be read physically rather than in e-reader form. You'll want to skip forward to follow each individual strand (a handy trick is to remember the first baby if you can). At its best, the novel is reminiscent of Elizabeth Jane Howard 's glorious Cazalet Chronicles, with the same casual metropolitan wealth and romantic intrigues. It may be a little careless around the edges -- could you really park a child in front of the television all day in 1966? Would Eva have had a word processor at home in 1977? -- while supporting characters such as Penelope, Eva's best friend, or Miriam, her saintly mother, are not so much sketchy as parsimonious ink dots. But the twists and turns of the central characters will keep you engrossed, the novel is very readable, and I thoroughly enjoyed the portrayal of the heroine Eva, an introverted, self-contained woman one cannot help liking. The appeal of Jim, apart from his purply eyes, was rather harder to spot, while pretty, selfish David, Eva's occasional alternate life partner, is far more fun: I could have done with rather more of him. While the book is not as gut-wrenching as David Nicholls's One Day, it is an unusual and lovely thing to watch an entire romance develop across a novel, not just the fun early bits, or unpleasant midlife startings-over, or male midlife crises disguised as literary novels. Its very scope is a joy, the technical achievement seamlessly done, and the ending -- all the endings -- suitably affecting, regardless of how winding the route one takes to get there. Your patience will be rewarded in more ways than one. * Resistance Is Futile by Jenny T Colgan is published by Orbit. To order The Versions of Us for [pound]9.99 (RRP [pound]12.99) go to bookshop.theguardian.com or call 0330 333 6846. Free UK p&p over [pound]10, online orders only. Phone orders min p&p of [pound]1.99. - Jenny Colgan.
Kirkus Review
The multiverse migrates out of science fiction for a fling with romance. Eva Edelstein, biking to class in 1958 at Cambridge, runs over a rusty nail. A tall, blue-eyed student, Jim Taylor, offers to fix her tire. In version one, she accepts his help and eventually marries him. In version two, she is muddled and marries a less-likely beau. In version three, Eva marries the same lesser bloke but makes a course correction midbook. In bite-sized alternating chapters, Eva's and Jim's lives spin along, apart and intersecting, together and fraying, over the next 56 years. Newcomer Barnett labels each chapter installment as version one, two, or three. This triple-braided structure builds poignancy, as the same 30th birthday party or funeral, populated by the same characters, unspools into different outcomes. So Eva is "plumping cushions" while Jim's lover Helena is "cleaning, tidying" in parallel but different stories as Jim paints a triptych he calls The Versions of Us. Children arrive, toddle, grow into sullen adolescence, and launch families of their own. Careers founder or flourish; infidelities are pursued. Pot is inhaled throughout the 1960s; tobacco is smoked to the end. In every era, cats are petted under their chins, and vats of alcohol swilled. Secondary charactersEva's best friend, Penelope; Jim's art dealer, Stephenare barely inhabited devices. Barnett, a British journalist writing her first novel about British journalist Eva trying to write her first novel, has a weakness for clichs and clunkers, such as "Do you see how beautiful we are?" Beauty is not enough, of course. Those readers particularly fond of the one-true-love trope will overlook what cloys. Others will long for the superior sentences and searing London Blitz scenes in Kate Atkinson's Life After Life, a much better multiverse novel. Still, this debut work, like three snowballs running downhill, gathers the old-fashioned Newtonian momentum of a good yarn. We see the consequences of small choices echoing through the years. Fans of the novel One Day and the movie Sliding Doors will want to pick up this debut. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Library Journal Review
Taking a leaf from Kate Atkinson's Life After Life, this touching novel looks at three different ways the lifelong romance between artist Jim Taylor and writer Eva Edelstein might have turned out. It begins with a chance meeting at Cambridge University in 1958 and then follows the pair over the years until the present. Jim and Eva marry, or maybe Eva marries the vain actor David Katz. Through the decades, they have various relationships that are both troubled and happy, bear a number of children, and endure plenty of family drama in England, Italy, France, and California. This clever and imaginative novel with intriguing characters presents three equally engaging stories. Yet switching among the three versions can become so confusing that readers may wish for a genealogy chart to keep everyone straight. VERDICT Reading this ambitious first novel is like putting together the pieces of a complex puzzle. The challenge pays off-only when the puzzle is complete can readers see the whole panoramic picture. [See Prepub Alert, 11/9/15.]-Leslie -Patterson, Rehoboth, MA © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.